S’mores Pudding in a Jar

birthday b

I like the play of the light in this picture. Birthday boy and his “cake”.

Every once in a while I get extremely creative. Yesterday, after two soccer games and then lunch with the fam (these are never short excursions), I made my son’s “cake” for his little party. He doesn’t like cake or anything really. Other than Golden Oreos and Baskin Robbins soft serve vanilla ice cream. So for the last three years he has gotten a monkey bread cake. He does love his cinnamon and sugar. After making the cake, I proceeded to make homemade Marshmallow Fluff. Oh boy, it was a huge batch. I really didn’t need all of it. So half went in the freezer. Then I made chocolate pudding, sorry folks, it was out of a box. Put together these pudding cups and jars. Put together the treat bags and realized it was already past time for the sleep over to have begun and the only boy here was the one that came early. They had loads of fun anyway. They slept outside in a tent, and played until well after dark. Being boys.

smores jars

S’mores Pudding in a Jar (or cup)

You will need:

  • Marshmallow Fluff (I made homemade)
  • Instant Chocolate Pudding (I used the bigger box but it depends on how many you want to serve)
  • Milk
  • Golden Grahams cereal (or other graham cracker goodness) Update: unless you are going to eat these right away, I don’t recommend the cereal. It got really soggy. I will stick to Biscoff cookies
  • Milk chocolate to shave or chop (mini MnMs would work too)
  • Small jars (I used 4 bowls as well because I didn’t have enough jars here, the rest are in storage)

Marshmallow Fluff ingredients  (makes probably 30oz)

  • 3 egg whites
  • 2 cups light corn syrup
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt
  • 2 – 3 cups powdered sugar, to taste
  • 1 – 1 1/2 Tablespoons vanilla extract, to taste, or other flavoring

Recipe adapted from Bombshell Bling

Now this is the recipe I ultimately used but not exactly. I started off using a different recipe so I actually whisked the egg whites first, then added 2 Tbsp of sugar and beat again until peaks formed. Then I started following the recipe above. I only added in 2 cups of powdered sugar and no vanilla. And the stuff was excellent and a little less sweet than store bought.

How to Make (the way I did it)

  1. Whisk egg whites in a large bowl, on high, until light and frothy
  2. Slowly add in 2 Tbsp sugar and continue whisking on high until small peaks form
  3. Add in corn syrup and salt and whisk for another 7 minutes, on high. Mixture will become large and fluffy
  4. Add in the powdered sugar, 2 cups at first, on low and mix until just blended. Taste. Add more powdered sugar to preference.
  5. At this point you can also add Vanilla, or any other flavoring, but I didn’t, knowing I was layering it with pudding.marshmallow fluff_edited-1
  • Set marshmallow fluff aside (I filled up a jar with some first, knowing I would need it next weekend to make the Rocky Road Cupcakes for my niece).
  • Make chocolate pudding according to box. I also used the whisk attachment on the mixture, on low, because it hurts my arm too much to do it by hand. Set pudding aside.
  • Crush Golden Grahams into large chunks and fill the bottom of the jars. (I also like to use Biscoff cookies.)cereal
  • Layer pudding on top of the cerealpudding
  • Layer Marshmallow Fluff on top of the pudding
  • Layer all three again
  • Top with chocolate shavings and whole cereal
  • Chill. Serve. Enjoy. If you used jars these will keep in the fridge for about 5 dayssmores cups
  • I partied here: Whipperberry and Crafaholics Anonymous



Published by Lili

Single mom trying to find fun and happiness thru the lens.

5 thoughts on “S’mores Pudding in a Jar

  1. Yum, these s’more pudding cups look yummy. We love monkey bread too, I hadn’t made it in quite some time and just picked up ingredients for it this past week, great idea for a fun birthday cake! 🙂


    1. Thank you April. The first time I made the Monkey Bread for a cake, I tore down a side and made it look like a cave with pirate figurines and gold. LOL.


  2. I am loving the homemade marshmallow cream!! I am so making that to curb my kids love of fluffer-nutters! My newly minted young “man” also had a tent sleepover for his birthday…there was even a fire ⊙▂⊙


    1. I have never made a fluffer-nutter…gotta try one of those. Thank you Krista for stopping by and leaving the kind words.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: